How can I tell whether an original study actually supports my claim?

Turn the claim into a specific statement with an outcome, population, and timeframe. Find the original report and compare those elements against its methods and results. Document precisely what the evidence permits you to say.

Auf Deutsch lesen

Step-by-step walkthrough

  1. Write the proposed claim at the top of a worksheet. Identify words that imply treatment effects, a broad population, or long-term follow-up.

  2. Locate the original study using the title and a stable identifier. Check the publisher record for the publication version and any posted corrections.

  3. Record the study design, who or what was measured, the exact outcome and observation window, and the location that supports each statement.

  4. Rewrite the claim to match the evidence. Keep unresolved information in a separate follow-up field and date the sources you examined.

Free practice example

A fictional public-library pilot compares a printed handout with a QR code for workshop instructions. The researchers record setup time for ten adult volunteers, but a publicity draft says the code improves learning across all ages. Replace that claim with one about the measured setup-time difference in the pilot and flag learning outcomes as unmeasured.

How to check your result

A second reader should be able to point to the same outcome and sample from your note. Check that the rewritten claim includes the observed context and that the original, stronger claim is retained only as an unanswered question.

Questions you can work through

How do I resolve two articles with similar titles?

Compare authors, study dates, journal and identifier. Retrieve the publisher record and match the article to the population and outcome you need.

What does a Crossref record tell me before I open the article?

It provides deposited bibliographic fields that help you identify the work and follow its DOI. Read the article to establish how the study was run and what results it reports.

How can I document a study when full text is unavailable?

Record the identifier, what you observed in public metadata or the abstract, and which details remain inaccessible. Keep the claim provisional until you can check the relevant passage.

When should a newsletter distinguish association from effect?

Whenever the distinction changes the claim. For an observational comparison, state the relationship in terms the underlying design can support and identify relevant limitations.

Where do I check if an article was updated after publication?

Start with the publisher record and look for explicit update, correction or retraction notices. Verify the affected table or conclusion and record the date checked.

How do I compare data from different follow-up windows?

Write each window beside its outcome and avoid combining figures measured over incompatible periods. Explain the difference before citing both studies in one passage.

What should a useful evidence note capture besides the quote?

Include study design, population, comparison, outcome and passage reference. The note should preserve context that an isolated quotation would lose.

How do I know whether a finding applies outside the study site?

Compare site, eligibility criteria and sample with the new context. Use a contextual inference label unless separate evidence supports the broader application.

How do I keep a source list from double-counting the same participants?

Look for linked registry IDs, overlapping recruitment periods and matching participant descriptions. Mark reports as linked where evidence indicates that they use the same sample.

How should I revise a draft when part of the claim lacks evidence?

Retain the verified component as a narrow statement. Turn the unverified component into a specific search question or clearly identify it as a hypothesis.

Frequently asked questions

Can I do the sample without a research subscription?

Yes. The worked example contains the inputs needed to classify the claim and its evidence.

Does a DOI mean the findings were independently replicated?

The identifier supports retrieval. Independent replication requires its own study evidence.

What if the prompt generates a polished but unverifiable reference?

Search for the exact record and replace or remove the citation when you cannot find the original. Keep the failed search in your notes.

Sources

Checked

Continue with the masterprompt

Original product files are in German. EUR 17.50 one-time.

✪ AISECRETS™ DER FORSCHER

Follow guides via RSS

Help & FAQ